TMI. LOL. BFF. TTYL. It’s fair to say that communication has changed drastically over the last couple of decades. Where once we would pick up the phone to call a close friend and dish about the latest news, we now fire off a 140 character message and broadcast that same info to hundreds or even thousands of friends and followers.
We all want to feel good about ourselves, so our natural inclination is to share the fantastic aspects of our lives: the fun concert, the cute baby pic, a job promotion, a photo of ourselves on a really good hair day. We focus on the best version of the truth, editing out the bad parts and instagramming the rest until we look shiny and gleamy and well-adjusted. Research supports our motivation to look good: “People with high self-esteem posting positive status updates [are] rewarded with more comments and ‘likes’ by their friends.” Converseley, those who don’t have a positive online presence receive negative reactions from their peers.

“Life is so much rose-petaled, pretty dress wearing fun! Aren’t you jealous? LOL! JK!” Ever feel bombarded by these images and sentiments on blogs, Facebook or Pinterest?
All of this immediacy offers us a strange new form of intimacy. We have more access to the everyday details of other people’s lives. But we can also hide the things we don’t want to share. What you see isn’t always what you get. When it comes to online presence, if you share only the good stuff, you’re bragging. And if you post too many negative remarks, you’re a Debbie Downer. Facebook and Twitter aren’t great platforms for big revelations. They encourage emotive, impulsive soundbites that fail to reveal the bigger picture. Someone’s in a bad mood, another is having a way better day than you are. It’s tough to relate to these tiny snippets because the motivation of the poster is so murky. That’s where blogs come in. Blogs allow us to say a lot or a little, to delve deep or skim the surface and, most importantly, to craft an ongoing narrative that shows more than one side of the story: a whole, imperfect human being.
There’s a little movement right now called “Things I’m Afraid to Tell You,” that was started by the blogger Jess Constable. She was tired of seeing only the pretty and perfect on blogs and challenged others to share the less glamorous aspects of their lives, their fears and imperfections. Design and lifestyle bloggers all over the net responded and posted lists of their not so positive traits: fear of rejection, failure, jealousy, marital troubles. Many were surprised to find that these intimate posts received the most views and positive feedback of any they’d ever written. Why do you think that is?
Maybe it’s because we’re being bombarded with bite after bite of the perfect and the depressing and not enough of the real. As our definition of intimacy morphs, we’re beginning to wonder whether there’s more meaning behind those pretty pictures and sarcastic tweets. We long for a more accurate version of the truth.
Here are a few things to think about before you impulsively hit publish on an emotional wall post or delete that difficult blog draft about a personal struggle:
What’s your motivation?
Why are you sharing something? Are you looking for an ego boost? Are you trying to make a person or group of people feel bad? Do you want to prove something to yourself or others? People can sense motivation in tone and content. As a reader, I can tell right away if someone is trying to position themselves as “better than” or begging for a bone. Share in order to connect, engage and help. Think about the why first and the what second.
Context is everything
You can share almost anything if it’s in the right context. You know those cryptic, one sentence posts you see on Facebook? Something along the lines of: “I knew this would happen again.” The poster has given us absolutely no context or back story. What happened again? Are they okay? Do they need help? Do they just want attention? Isn’t that what runs through your mind when you see that sort of one-liner? It’s the same with blog posts. Sometimes I walk away wondering why the heck someone shared so much information about their relationship because they never put it in the proper context. Revealing simply to unburden yourself is a bit selfish. Don’t just vent. Teach me something, make me feel, make me laugh, engage me, make a connection. If you can do that, you can reveal as much about yourself as you’d like, and I’ll be hanging on your every word.
How does it make you feel?
Sometimes we don’t share things because they make us feel vulnerable. We’re worried about being judged so we package ourselves as well-coiffed, perfect little bloggers. Vulnerability is a good thing. We can all stand to be more vulnerable in our daily lives and in our blogs. Vulnerability isn’t about over-sharing or jeopardizing your emotional well-being. It’s about pushing through the need to be seen a certain way and letting go of that vice-grip on image control.
Who will it help?
If there’s one thing blogging has taught me, it’s that a lot of people are struggling with the same difficult life choices. By sweeping all of the ugly, unpleasant stuff under the proverbial rug, we’re missing out on an opportunity to connect with and help others. Sharing the fact that I struggled with depression as an adolescent made me feel vulnerable. But I know that a lot of people have gone through or are currently going through the same thing. I’m free to bury it in the past and portray myself as perfectly well-adjusted. But I choose to share it in the hope that it will help someone else feel less alone.
Where do you weigh in on social media and selective sharing? Do you think we share too much or not enough? What do you feel comfortable sharing and why?
Tagged: blogging, facebook, How Much to Reveal Online, opinion, privacy, Social media over-sharing, TMI, truth

Thanks, Rian, for this thoughtful reflection on our motivations – and responsibilities – in the realm of social media. I love the idea of “Things I’m afraid to tell you…” I’ve nominated you for The Versatile Blogger award because I’m enjoying your posts so much.
I wish I could write like you.
So many things to comment on this post though I’ll pick one. Vulnerability.
For some reason, over the past year, each month I keep making this list of the Top 100 Coaches to Follow on Twitter. I’m humbled and curious as to why me?
Possibly it’s because I say what’s on my mind. I’m not trying to be the “perfect” human being. I post things that are relevant that people can relate to.
I’ve never learned anything from a person who’s world is peachy. Bull!
I want to hear from the person that screwed up. They fell on their ass, scraped their knees, broke a bone or two, and lived to tell about it.
Be authentic. To get there, start being vulnerable.
I agree be authentic……I have always been critised for being too open with people. I have nothing to hide.. Have I made mistakes… Yes some whoppers! Would I change a thing .. Never!
Reminds me of a poem I love. It goes something like this.
“I walked a mile with pleasure, she chatted all the way,
But I was none-the-wiser for what pleasure had to say.
I walked a mile with sorrow, and not a word said he.
But, Oh, the things I learned the time when sorrow walked with me.
Hello! I’m using this for one of my Media Literacy sessions in my English Communication classes. Very very useful and insightful. Of course, I will reference your blog. Great post!
Hi Shelley! I’m so glad you found this post useful, and I’m honored that you’re using it for your class. I’d love to hear what ideas you guys come up with and discuss on the topic :)
Just a thought here: I recently read an online discussion where the blogger and her commenters were debating the term “transparency” versus “opacity” in the context of social media. I love the distinction — we often hear about Facebook/Twitter/blogs allowing us to be transparent, but perhaps opaque is a better term. I used to teach college writing courses and thought at the time that this would make a great classroom debate, so when I saw your comment…just had to share! :)
Mikalee! This exactly what we discussed in class…how Social Media makes us feel intimate with one another, but not really! It’s a media fallacy of sorts. It was a fun class and we got to assess ourselves as well. Thanks for the tip!
and again, many thanks, Rian. You helped educate my students. ;)
Great Post! I try really hard to NOT GO TMI and find the right balance in my blog posts and sharing on SM sites:) Have a Great Day!
SM Sites. That made me smile.
I’m now inspired to do “Things I’m afraid to tell you”!! It’s all about being human, taking the good with the bad (and other similar cliches!). If someone is just constantly complaining, whining or oversharing, that’s not cool. I like authentic vulnerability which includes both ends of the scale. Great post! You’re always making me think…so thanks.
I hope you go for it, Tobi! I loook forward to reading it. You’re right, authentic vulnerability includes the good, the bad, and some of the messy in between.
Reblogged this on MaraProse.
Oh, Rian, how do you always know just what to write? Your insights hit me like a ton of bricks and I find myself at fault for a lot of the qualities you mentioned. I recently wrote a post about volunteering. Before I started, I had wanted to share, inspire, and make my readers think about what helping someone means. Rereading it after I read your post, it looks like a complete brag sheet. How could I have forgotten everything I wanted to say and just went on and on about what I had done? Your post reminded me that with sharing I also need to explain why I’m sharing a particular story and I will definitely remember that from here on out. You’re slowly making each of us better bloggers… Thanks! :-)
Hi Jessica, I think your volunteer work sounds amazing. And your post read like a first-hand account, which has a ton of merit. Now I understand more about that organization and what it would be like to volunteer for them. You taught me something and you made me feel, I didn’t take it as a brag sheet at all. It can be tough when we’re so close to something we’ve written to see it clearly and to guess how a reader will it interpret it. But I really enjoyed it! Don’t be so hard on yourself! This coming from someone who is also too hard on herself ;)
Me? Hard on myself? Nooooooo…. ;-) Thank you for reading and the feedback. I’m glad it didn’t come off all “aren’t-I-great-because-I-did-a-good-thing” because that was definitely not the intent. I think that you are completely right about being too close to our own writing. I’ll promise not to bee too hard on myself if you do the same. =)
I had this conversation (with myself) yesterday evening after looking at a Facebook post. I thought, ‘who really cares?’ The post was someone ranting and searching for dramatic pity than actual help or suggestions. Ok, fair, I rant too…I often stop myself before posting, tweeting, Instagramming though, to think about what is actually going on that I feel the need to share it with my closest billionth friend. Many times I end up logging out without posting anything so I can be in the moment and feel every ounce of what’s going on–good, bad, or indifferent. Social media is one heck of an awesomely powerful tool and I’m grateful for it, but being present is just as powerful for me. Another fabulous post my lady! :)
I was just discussing this with a friend today. Facebook can be so depressing sometimes – we compare ourselves to the online version of our friends and acquaintances. What a veil to look through! Thanks for this, love your post as always!
I wish we were discussing more of the real, the funny, the nitty gritty, the in between blah. Maybe it would actually connect us more.
I had a lunch date the other day with a friend and we laughed at the idea of taking pictures with all the babies and dogs we saw as if they were our own. She said it would be the kind of Facebook album that says, “Look how perfect my life is!” It was funny though because it was true.
I agree that blogging is the perfect place for it. Facebook and twitter are too short to truly get to the meat. Sure, you can come up with brilliantly crafted sentences and post your interesting pictures of your city/child/Saturday afternoon, but what are you really telling me?
Thanks for posting! Great tips by the way (BTW).
Thought provoking post… :D
Loved your post…I am proud, not to be on Facebook or Twitter ; if I was there, I would have been the most depressed person, imagining what perfect lives others had !!!
thats good
I got over the reluctance to be transparent a long time ago. An another note, I’m fascinated by how some use social media to feed their passive-aggressive appetite.
I think we are definitely sharing too much in the wrong way. In my opinion, a blog is an appropriate place to vent about your struggles or brag about your next trip IF you are bringing something beneficial to the reader at the same time. I also wrote a post a while back about how Facebookis lowering our self esteem. Twitter… I am still figuring out. Twitter seems to be more for connecting with people you don’t necessarily know, who share similar interests. It literally doesn’t allow for elaboration, which I think is fitting. If someone is intrigued by what I am posting on Twitter, they can click my blog link to dig deeper.
Hi Becca, I enjoyed your post! There’s a lot to think about when it comes to how and why we share info online. Right now, social media feels kind of like a fun toy. But there’s always going to be a new toy. I remember coming across the idea a while back that Facebook is just a glorified chat room. And how often do you go into a chat room anymore? Social media as we currently know it will eventually morph into something new. In the meantime, we’ll have to continue tweaking our navigation tools.
You are absolutely correct! I still can’t get over how integrated it all is as well. It is like sort of like a never-ending loop!
Funny how your post comes on my way now- I just wrote a first draft about the nervous breakdown I had three years ago. I’m not sure I’ll ever publish it on my blog because it makes me feel vulnerable. At the same time, I want to share my experience in a hope to connect with other people in distress. I also wanted to tell the truth- terrible moments are buried behind my pretty-looking life. I’m still unsure what to do but your post adds something to my reflection :-)
Cecile, if you aren’t sure what you should do, here’s a tip – it’s called ‘asking the universe’. What you do is light a candle and say ‘universe, should I post this on my blog?’ I’m sure you’ll get the answer you need! Try it!
Hi Cécile, I think sharing our stories is so important. Someone will always be uncomfortable with it, I can promise you that. But that’s their issue, not yours. You have a truth that many people will be able to relate to. That’s empowering. I hope you find the right platform and words to go forward with it, but even writing it for yourself is a huge accomplishment. I’ve written many things that have never seen the light of day. Just telling the story to myself was enough. You’ll have to make that decision for yourself. But if you ever do publish it in some form, I would love to read it.
Thank you Rian for your ever so kind and supportive words. I already felt lighter after writing the story. Now I have to decide whether I want to share it, and if so, where. Maybe I’ll just ask the universe just like Andrew suggested (it’s actually a technique I use and the title of an upcoming post that Mr Mischievious proofread for me ;-))
I definitely think we’re sharing too much…there is something to say about keeping some of your cards close…there are only a few people in each person’s life who need to know absolutely everything about that person. For example, a student of mine posted an explicit Facebook status 2 days ago that essentially reported to thousands about his intimate sexual preferences. He shared a visual to support his claim. I deleted him. I honestly don’t care what he does with his private life, but the point this student missed somewhere along the way ( and I think a lot of people miss as well) is that social media IS NOT PRIVATE.
I started my blog because I have kept true stories that are very unusual bottled inside me for many years and I am a teacher who would like to help other artist. Yes, I am worried that others will roll there eyes but at the same time it is very freeing for me and I hope for others who read my blog. This post of yours is wonderful and you are helping a lot of people! KUDOS !!!!
There will always be eye-rollers. But if we wanted to please everyone, the only solution would be to say nothing. I’m glad you’re out there, taking chances. It inspires the rest of us to do the same!
Hey Girl, So glad that you got this boost it is well deserved! Congratulations and enjoy the Ride!
Thanks for this thought provoking + insightful post. Social media rarely gives a broad picture of how one’s life really is. For the most part, it’s like dating; we try to put our best foot forward—editing out our foibles. There is a fine line balancing sharing “too much” or “too little.” I find on Facebook I give short comments. I think I will analyze my reasons for doing that. I feel most comfortable sharing other people’s work, stories, etc. than my own. With Twitter, I try to focus on varied interests in my life. I am working on interacting more. Once again, great post that I will definitely share on Twitter. Reason: Giving others an opportunity to reflect on their social media habits.
Oh man, I wish we were sharing some cake (and champagne) right now! I definitely have a problem with the social media over share if the intent is skewed, exactly like you’ve said. I think that’s why I’m drawn so much to you and this blog – of course the writing is great, but I’ve always gotten the sense that you’re telling it like it is, in the hopes that it will help others. People DEFINITELY can pick up on intent even when it’s not blatant; you’re so right about that.
I tend to be a little glossy in some ways on my blog, not going into the darker stuff and keeping it pretty PG overall, but the entire theme was ‘guilty pleasures’ to hopefully make people feel like they could let down their hair a little and not be all, “Oh, I only watch black and white films with subtitles.” LOL One of the big lessons I’ve learned from blogging, is that embarrassing stories can make the best comedy ;) When I first posted about Talbots telling me to wear curvy pants, I got a HUGE response (comparatively speaking)! It allowed me to not hesitate when I posted about being mortified during that team-building exercise!
Can’t wait to check out Jess’s blog! I’m still thinking about your last post; the reverse psychology article about small changes really stuck with me.
“Oh, I only watch black and white films with subtitles.” But don’t you? ;) You’re totally right. I don’t think that truth has to be told in a super serious way. Some of the most impactful stuff is humorous. A lot of comedians/funny writers had horrible childhoods. It’s a way to communicate the pain without exploding in the process. My favorite is the mix–where someone can make you laugh and then BAM, hit you in the gut with something 100% real. I read some of the comments on your last post. And I find that discussion fascinating–if you’re a humorous blogger, can you step outside of that box? Is being serious allowed? And I saw some interesting resistance to the idea over there. I think it’s fantastic that you started that sort of conversation and that you took a chance and stepped out of your box. That’s not an easy thing to do, and you did it really, really well. You’re a multi-talented fearless gal, Jules!
My problem is that there is just too much drama on the internet already with all the news about the economy and natural disasters and human rights abuses. So I like to read something that is a little light and will give me a break from work. As I mentioned in here:
http://funnyphuppo.wordpress.com/2012/05/07/around-the-internet-in-90-minutes/
So I would much rather read something like Jules or ByronicMan’s blog at that time. If you can fit something real in there, like you suggested, Rian, then that’s great. Otherwise there is enough drama in my life to wish to not be depressed by the drama in the life of others.
Thank you so much, funnyphuppo! I agree there needs to be some safe zones where you can go and get away from all of the drama, and I’m so flattered you think of my blog as one of those places :)
*need to be. Oops!
Very insightful tips, thanks.
Hmm…I think I would rather post positive things on Facebook/Twitter/Wordpress than my complaints or dislikes (“If you don’t have anything nice to say, then don’t say it.”). I try not to brag too much or excessively gloss over negatives, though I can’t guarantee I don’t.
Part of the reason for a positive gloss is that my Twitter and WordPress account are 100% “public” and ANYBODY can read them – close friends, colleagues, casual acquaintances – so I’d rather I didn’t come across as negative/unstable/unlikeable via those media. On Facebook where my security is tighter I vent more.
Thanks again for all the intellectual cake you provided us with. :)
I agree with you–it’s very tough to be an authentic, well-rounded person on Facebook and Twitter. I think, moving forward, that those types of platforms will become even more about our public persona and less about who we really are as people. Young people tend to friend everyone they meet. It’s a way to stay connected in the virtual world. But, as we continue to expand communication online, I feel like there needs to be a place where we can say more of the “real” things. I don’t know what that will be in the future, but for now, I feel like blogs are filling that void.
My dad, my mother-in-law, everyone reads this blog. At first, I wanted to sort of control the what and the who of it all. But I’m finding that the best, easiest way for me to function within all of these new social media realms is to just be myself. Most people really don’t mind. In fact, they tend to embrace it. The people I most admire are those who can be themselves in any situation.
Thanks for chiming in!
I agree. I am hoping my blog will try to do what yours is.
Scott
When I began blogging I tried to express myself and I didn’t know if someone will read what I have to say…
I feel comfortable sharing hope, if it’s possible…. as once I wrote, I know I came to this life to be happy, in spite of I’m not happy everyday.
Keep writting Rina, I really enjoy reading you ;)
love
Carla
Blogging for me is as distinctive as a fingerprint. I don’t want to get into judging the content of someones inner thoughts. Mine started out as a book club blog and then morphed into a journal of sorts that was driven by requests from women I had forged strong bonds with. My posts are random and have to do with what I am dealing with at that moment/day. I never write them because I think they can help someone. They help me.
I am constantly amazed by the messages we receive from the universe of collective experience. Vulnerable is real. Vulnerability is not always pretty and pink but it’s what sets us apart. I don’t like everyone’s postings everyday, I don’t always like mine, but I find gems when I least expect it and need them the most. Reminders that I am not terminally unique. Sharing life’s burdens and joys just plain helps.
I think some people share too much but I don`t feel like too many of us share too little.
We need a little privacy & selective sharing isn’t too bad when it comes to certain topics.
This post is the first of your posts that I’ve had the privilege to read. As an introvert, it’s always easier for me to share my thoughts via written words. Writing allows me to communicate with others more comfortably and, hopefully, always authentically. The more we all learn to share, the easier communication becomes. I do reserve the nitty-gritty for my BFFs. However, I do share my heartfelt experiences that often include tears, to help others. I forward to reading more of your posts. Thank you, thank you.
Reblogged this on It's A Wonderful Life and commented:
Everything about this post is fantastic. Enjoy.
I recently went through a period where I felt disillusioned with social media and kind of like I was lost between two worlds – the real one and my online world. I wrote a post about it too, talking about how the lines blurred and how it affected decisions I made. It wasn’t exactly on what you’ve talked about, but reading your post has helped put my own feelings more in context and made them clearer.
Thanks for that :)
The most thoughtful, thorough, and accurate news sources are disappearing, being replaced by sources that spend the same amount of time reporting on a bombing in Syria and a guy who has been stealing Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups from the same 7-11 for the past 6 months. A news website made its founder exceedingly wealthy, and the business model was to run all news sources through a sieve and plagiarize whatever they wanted. Bring up the corruption and illegal activities carried out by American banks, and the common responses are to ignore, deny, change the subject, and to be accused of being a downer, or a cynic. Looking at media, in all forms, the unifying characteristic is instant gratification. People pay over $100 per month, so they can have access to a GPS-mapping system they can rarely operate effectively, so they can inform the world they just arrived at Quik Trip to buy a Rooster Booster, so they can make/break plans with people from moment to moment, and never have to feel locked into any decision.
“Real” is depressing. Everyone has bad days, but how many actually respond in kind when asked? It’s because there are only a select few we each know who will not judge us for what we say or how we say it. Rather than waiting for the individual to fully explain, many listeners are constantly looking for cues in the first couple of sentences someone reports, then formulating a generic response, based on something from a textbook, a new report, etc. Meanwhile, the person has been trying to explain a problem, but the listener has not been listening. Whether or not pithy communication being the norm is a good or bad thing, is moot. The status quo has shifted, and just like old English and middle English are no longer spoken, modern English, as the primary form of communication, has undergone change. It is time to accept, and eventually, hopefully, embrace.
Freshly pressed twice!!!…Now I am just jealous ;)
Great post.
One of the challenges of writing about feelings, painful or otherwise, is that most bloggers — no polite way to say this — are amateur writers, who have never been (heavily) edited, and who have little experience polishing their prose to the point they know (or care) that it’s going to work well and make sense to thousands of readers. They write for themselves, mistaking a blog, which is public and permanent, for their private journal. They fail to get the essential element you describe, which is to remember you’re writing for others, not just for yourself.
One trend I’ve seen, which I have a lot of difficulty with, is people oversharing on Facebook about their medical issues, including (!) photos and lurid descriptions of their cuts, chemo and worse. Seriously? I find it gross, in poor taste and it makes me wonder why they feel compelled to publicize such material. Intimacy with thousands of strangers is a very odd notion.
Such a lovely dress and such epic pictures! Simply beautiful
Beautiful!
I would like to say that I disagree with “broadsideblog” about those who share their experiences going through chemo. Having lost many to different forms of cancer, the emotional support many receive through their story and experiences shared online can help not only them but others facing the same challenges.
Thank you for sharing and hope to read more.
Reblogged this on Anything Interesting on WordPress.
Reblogged this on Greetings from England and commented:
An excellent thought-provoking piece on ‘sharing online’, which I simply must share with all!
the only social media i am now involved with is this blog….blogging is great..and very fukllfilling and educational..my cell phone has been switched off and left in the draw for over a year…all that twitter twatter facebook mixit crap is just that…crap.
ohh sorry….not fukfilling…….not fuk at all….sorry
you are so right. the only thing i am in to is blogging or trying to email.
Excellent, excellent post! Very well-written and informative. This is very relevant to all of our lives today, and you really tackled the issue. I’ll be keeping this in mind.
Maybe one reason that many people only show their best self online is also due to the fact that once it’s posted, it stays there. I love the interaction with other bloggers and learn much from them. But I am reluctant to reveal too much about myself for security reasons.
the same here. i am dont what to let out any info about me but only what i see. read my blog to know more.
This is an interesting point. But I wonder about the future of online privacy. It feels like we may eventually live so much of our lives online that attaining any real level of privacy will become next to impossible. Maybe we’ll continue to split ourselves in half, creating a “work” image and a “personal” image. I’m already finding it so much work that I’m starting to just blend them together: what you see is what you get. But it also depends on your field and how disparate your public and private personas actually are.
Thank you so much for writing this. It is well written and a subject I am glad somebody has tackled. Having recently deleted both facebook and twitter (due to a man I was in love with getting a new girlfriend, and her posting a million tweets about their relationship together, which KILLED ME :( ) it got me thinking. If we are all “in love” why are we declaring it to the world via a social net working site? It smacks of trying to prove a point, which never actually proves anything.
Thank you again for writing this, you are definitely right about blogging it shows all sides of a persons character rather than one carefully and manipulatively crafted side cut down to 140 characters.
Emma xoxo
I hate it when on facebook people constantly post about their relationships, I mean, I’m happy for them, but do they need to add ‘love you [insert name here]‘ at the end of every status, even the ones which have nothing to do with their relationship? Also, attention seeking posts are worse, especially when they then act offended if you ask what’s wrong because now you’re prying.
Blogging is definitely more rewarding and even educational and you don’t feel as though you have to hide your imperfections.
Thanks for the brilliant, insightful post :)
http://mystudentstruggles.wordpress.com
facebook is not my thing.
What a wonderfully thought provoking post. I don’t know about anyone else, but I started blogging as a way to get ‘back’ to writing. I love films so I write about those. But I also have thoughts that I just want to put down. I put it out there just to see if anyone has similar thoughts or feelings. I discovered blogging quite late, but I’m becoming slightly addicted to it. Where else could I read such inspirational and informative words…for free. :-)
It is amazing how many fantastic, well-written thoughts are just floating around out there, free of charge. Social media seems to provide this somewhat false sense that we’re communicating in a meaningful way. But it only allows us to touch the tip of the iceberg. Blogging has really opened up a whole new world of communication and exchange that I didn’t even know existed. I hope it’s done the same for you.
It most certainly has. I am constantly amazed at the writers I “bump” into on the net. :-)
A wonderful read first thing in the morning. And so true!
I feel strongly for this post. I do shy away from facebook because I felt like my thoughts “turned to statuses” don’t deserved the irrational comments people threw back in there. If you put something so personal people would judge you as emotional dope. Blogging is comforting and a great venue for all the feelings and deep thoughts we could have and create. It justifies all the whirling states and clears the confusion within. It makes us whole again from the everyday disasters of life.
Thank you for this post, as you said, “But I choose to share it in the hope that it will help someone else feel less alone.” and I really feel not so alone.
What a brilliant post. I started blogging not that long ago and made the decision to do it anonymously for the very reason I wanted to be open, honest and real. I know that if I thought people I already kn
I love you speak of vulnerability and the effect it has on other people. Great post.
I went old school, I deleted my facebook and decided to call/meet up with my friends instead.
that is so true and down to earth.
Yes, once upon a time, scanning through a news feed had the potential to make me feel, in comparison to what I read in people’s status updates, like I live a very boring life. Then I thought, “Wait! I’m ‘checking-in’ at the same awesome places, having the same great experiences, have talented friends, do good work, etc.” I’m just out there living it (and sometimes blogging about it) instead of writing about it in a status update. Although, when I hit a concrete post last week in the Whole Foods parking garage, I put it in a quick status update about it, because it made me laugh. People! Keep your medical histories and the details of your divorce proceedings to yourselves, please. Thank you. Or better yet, I just won’t spend my time reading about them. :)
On an ironic note, I’m going to share this post on FB.
Rian what a great post! Clear guidelines for everyone out there that wants to share information with friends and strangers. Keeping in mind what kind of energy you are generating and providing to others is important. Honesty and positive energy (not perfect but positive) will attract the same. Thanks
A little of both for me.
If your banner pic is actually NOT you, than I’d say NOT ENOUGH truth. If it is you, then . . . well, thanks for the frosting ;)
Rock On!
Nope, I just like to masquerade as a blonde, cupcake eating chick who likes ceramic pigs ;)
Great post, Rian. And I totally agree that people share far too much about themselves on social media sites. Of course, I just started a blog and fear that I’m falling into the same trap since the subject I know the most about is myself. Nevertheless, I do it not because I think I’m any better than my readers or feel like bragging, but because I long to make meaningful connections with others. Thanks for giving me some insight on how to achieve some balance in my posts. All the best! Scott (gnosticbent.wordpress.com)
I love reading people’s personal stories–it’s what gives a piece authority and makes it human. I’m not suggesting anyone leave their personal lives out of their writing–rather the opposite–share the vulnerable parts, put it in context, connect with me as a reader. Sounds like you’re doing a great job!
Thanks, Rian! Right back at you!
Brilliant, thank you. I’ve been reading some Timothy Leary lately and struck by his proposal that our brains become addicted the stimulus of things like TV, and now FB, Twitter, email etc. I spent June trying to get the monkey off my back.
Anyway, I loved your post. Very well written.
Yep, that’s the scary part. If we look at it realistically, we’re like rats going back for more of the sweet stuff. I know it’s true for me–if I shut off for a few days, I don’t miss the internet at all. In fact, I sort of dread going back to it because I know it’s going to suck me right back in.
Here is the first of a few posts on my social media addicted brain. http://smplefy.wordpress.com/2012/06/01/dropping-out/
Absolutely wonderful post! This is the type of posts that should be Freshly Pressed, so that the others bloggers can get to know it! Every single thing you told in this post are true. Congrats on being Freshly Pressed! :)
Thank you very much. This blog has been insightful. I have just recently started to blog. Your blog has me thinking about the subject I chose to write about.
same here i just started blogging i read yours if you read mine.
Thank you!
Good luck on your blogging adventure! I’ve only been at it for about three and a half months but it’s a lot of fun (and challenging). My suggestion? Write about what interests you–chances are someone else will also be interested in the same thing. Don’t try to write what you think people want to hear. And keep going! Don’t let the bumps in the road throw you off. Take care!
I’ve recently been feeling that Social networking sites like Facebook and Twitter only thrive because of our desire for fame.
I doubt if one person posts a status or a comment without wondering how people will react when they see it, without hoping for people to like it or to reply, but simply just to make a connection.
(As for the “Like” button, what could possibly ruin conversation more? If I see a post I agree with, I no longer express my opinion in words, I simply click “Like” and move on.)
And yet here I am: hoping that by commenting here people will respond to my comment and visit my blog, because I’m exactly the same.
Love your insight about the “Like” button. It’s so true–it allows you to participate without expressing a single thought except for: “Hey, I was here! Look at me!” It allows us to feel like we’re conversing, but we’re really just talking to ourselves.
This is such a great post! I have never thought about social media like this. More people need to read this.
http://stepstochangetheworld.wordpress.com/
I don’t even have a Facebook or Twitter, so all I can talk about is my blog; however, I can say that I started my blog as a way to get my writing out there. Now blogging’s a rewarding experience where I can talk with people about aspects of writing, books, and other stuff I’m interested in.
Hello Rian, yours is the first blog I’ve read since I started.
I’m new to blogging and my posts are a little ascerbic, but I think very honest and quite amusing. They will probably offend many in the way that home truths do – or it might just be my choice language – but I thought I’d give one or two a read before I continue, and yours was quite interesting, and you do seem popular.
In my experience many people’s social media personas are not authentic. FB (I don’t know what TMI, BFF or TTYL are) and the like are great ways to present a life not so ordinary to a world of friends not so real. There was a fascinating documentary on Channel 4 last year ago about a filmmaker that built up a friendship with the mother of a junior art prodigy on Facebook. He decided to drop in to visit this young woman as a surprise, but when he arrived there it turn out the mother had fabricated herself and this fantasy family of beautiful people. It was quite creepy at first but when he delved deeper into why the woman had done it, it turned out that through this fabricated family and world she had created, she was in some way making up for a life that had turned out to be unfulfilled .
Having started to write this reply to your posting (which I did quite enjoy – your posting not writing my reply, but I’m enjoying that too since I’m having a frustrating day in work and my boss who sits at the desk besides me has just left for the day so I can while away the next two hours surfing the net without feeling paranoid) I’ve kind’ve lost the thread of what I was going to say… oh yeah; contrived Facebook personas. Social media has become the same as rubbish TV and movies – it tends to present life in soft-focus, with make up, and special effects to make everything look better. Why? For the same reason people love movies and rubbish TV – escapism. People could be more real on FB and SM but life is too real for most as it is. People perhaps should share more on SM (or even share S&M) , but because of the way western society is, in cyberspace nobody wants to here you moan. Those random out of context one sentence status updates you refer to are more for those people who want somebody to ask ‘what’s up?’. These people are likely to be lonely, or like most of us, unfulfilled in their lives. The irony being, taking as read the veneers of reality that people post up on FB, their time spent on FB reading about everyone else’s fantastic lives probably isn’t helping to alleviate their own feelings of unfulfillment and lonliness.
I confess to getting down on occasion when I read how wonderful some people’s lives on FB are, then I realise two things 1) I know most of these people and I know that their lives aren’t that great – which sadly fills me with a sense of schadenfreude; 2) when I’m having a great time, I have no time to be posting every little detail on Facebook – I’m too busy enjoying real life.
PS: Is my reply too long? I type very fast and I really need to use the loo.
I so enjoyed your post. thank you for sharing it.
Oh! My God!!! I wish I’d read this 5 years ago when I started writing in my blog. After a couple of years I had to turn it into a private affair because it became undeniably apparent that I am undeniably insane. That all emerged from the basic premise I set for myself in the beginning: “I will not censor myself…” If you hear yourself muttering something like that it’s time for a consultation with some higher authority. Even though I made my blog private I suffered a period a few months ago where I had 3 laptops stolen within 5 weeks setting in motion a nightmare panic attact scenario where I suddenly realized “OMG!!! The entire world probably know now (cause I’m usually too lazy to sign off) that I’m incurably insane and not the pretty, funny, ha ha I’m crazy too kind of insanity…NO…this is scary crazy. Even I can see it, which I’m told, is unusual for the crazy person themselves, so I must assume that even I do not see what the outside observer sees…CONTEXT…why didn’t I think about that? But I did! I wrote about it! I worried about it! But I wrote without it anyway. I violated about 100 other basic rules for blogging too which are just beginning to seep back into my awareness in the form of nightmares and panic attacks…so even though my blog is private now I worry…is it really? No, of course not. Every fucking thing I write is written. Just think…every single thing we right is now WRITTEN…even erasing does not and cannot erase that fact…it is now WRITTEN…I know…back to therapy…easy for you to say…I can’t afford someone I might benefit from seeing and I certainly can’t afford cupcakes…sherbert yes…I can afford sherbert…thank God!
Witty and inspirational! Thank you for this wonderful post. :)
Reblogged this on gratitudecoaching and commented:
Your blog has inspired me so much. A great read with so many thoughts whirling around in my head…. Like you say the message needs to say something. I will be mindful of that everytime I blog…. Congratulations on a fabulous piece of writing
Such a fascinating topic. I think there is a fine line in the social mediasphere between crafting an image and reflecting an image … and we all tread it often! Of course, I blog about some of the you-just-can’t-make-this-sh*t-up moments in my life — but not all of them, to be sure.
In my specific case, I began my blog to deal with some of the painful realities of a blindsiding divorce. As I’m sure you can imagine, there was some early backlash that I was reflecting that reality at all…in our society, I think the standard prescript is for us to keep our heads down and lay low while going through experiences like divorce, but I was compelled to give voice to something that was somewhat taboo. Because of this, I’ve been able to build an amazing community, and we support one another so much through it all — what started for me was a blog dedicated solely to divorce, but it has evolved into something much bigger about life in general — all with a humorous, snarky, tongue-in-cheek undercurrent. I love to see others’ thoughts and opinions about some of the less sexy aspects of life — fascinating stuff.
Thank you for sharing this amazing post. I mentioned this above in response to another commenter, but I think it’s worth sharing again: There is a huge difference between transparency (which is the term bandied about often in the context of social media outlets like Facebook and Twitter) and opacity. I think “opaque” describes it much more precisely.
Spot. On.
Great blog :)
Great post! In the interest of full disclosure, my coif could use some work today.
Mine too ;)
When I first got involved in all this social media hoopla I was amazed. It was possible to stay in contact with someone anywhere in the world and at the drop of a hat. I could know everything about a person just by clicking a mouse and I could share what I wanted to. But, there came a point when I realized that it was becoming too much. People were living for the internet. Making sure to snap pictures of things that made them look cool, possibly to make others jealous. People were putting their whole lives on Facebook and whatnot, and I couldn’t help but wonder why. So I got off. I spent years not touching it… now I am back but I use it as a way to stay in touch. I remain honest, and only speak in the way I would in person. I am a writer/blogger and I make sure to do the same with my blog. Of course writing everything makes you feel vulnerable, or it is a picture you rather not paint, but I think that I owe it to myself to let it all go. I have been blogging for a long time, and recently started this blog, so that I could say things I couldn’t say on my primary blog, that was my choice because some things need to be more private. But there is a world to live out there. Outside of the internet, everyone should take advantage of it.
This is a great start to the conversation, but I think there is a part of the discussion that still needs to be had. As writers of posts (Twitter/Facebook/Blogs) we all have our motives. To share, to entertain, to seek attention. But what about those that read those posts? What are the motives there? On either side of the discussion, I’m not sure it’s necessary to define the reasons. Maybe those reasons change. Mine did.
I started socializing online as a way to promote my work. I’ve found that I enjoy the discussions, and that the people I’ve net-met have been inspiring and encouraging. And though I have a pretty loyal following, I know my content isn’t for everyone. Heck, there are 7 billion people in this world…I know I’m not for everyone! :)
I have encountered the one-liners need for attention. Some are total drama queens, needing others to reach out to them to pull more info out. It happens. Those methodologies exist offline as well. However, I’ve encountered some that simply want to vent. The internet can be a safe place to simply toss a thought into the aether and let it fly or dissipate. The point of the poster is to simply externalize it. Some aren’t looking for attention, they’re engaging in self-therapy.
It is a complex conversation. The thing that I LOVE most about your post is that it keeps the conversation going. You have a wonderful writing style that helps with that. Thanks for sharing your thoughts…
Hi Rian,
Thanks for airing this matter in such a succinct way – well done!
As an “older person” I have observed a vast difference in between how social interaction was done in the “old days”, vs. now. In the “old days” people communicated face-to-face, and seemed to have been far more interested in the other person than in trying to blow their own bugle all of the time. This feeling usually was reciprocated. Nowadays it seems to be all about “look at me and how great I am”.
What I do see is that everyone is so anxious to be not forgotten, that a lot of the stuff on the social media actually are worthless in the grander scope of things. Advertising where you are now, and what you are doing, smacks of a high level of insecurity, that is if you are not doing something truly spectacular at the time? And if what you are doing is not spectacular, then surely it is all about me, and being very superficial me at that!
I do accept that the technology has made it possible to stay in touch with family and friends scattered all over the world, but when you do want to communicate on a sincere level, then you need the personal touch. This can not be done using social media. Suppose that your wife/husband/lifelong partner is diagnosed with untreatable cancer – do you inform all of your Facebook/Twitter/blog followers, or will you only inform your close friends?
If you really care about someone, and you want to have some meaningful contact, pick up the phone, write an email, or even write a good old fashioned letter. This will show that you genuinely are interested in the other person, in how they are doing, and that you expect a reply from one person only. I can guarantee you that the few responses received will far outweigh the hundreds (or even thousands) of social media one-worder or one-liner replies, in terms of sincerity.
I love your post! I would agree with everything in it except that “Revealing simply to unburden yourself is a bit selfish.” For me that’s the whole point of blogging. I figure if people don’t want to read it, they don’t have to. (Maybe if I were trying to get lots of readers, I would reconsider!)
:)
My husband and I had this same conversation yesterday. If you post cheery stuff, you’re fake. If you publish the bad, you’re a drama queen. No way to win.
I loved your post! You have found a new follower here, your style of writing and the topics you choose are stellar. Big fan :)
What a brilliant post. I started blogging not that long ago and made the decision to do it anonymously for the very reason I wanted to be open, honest and real. If I thought that people I already knew where reading it I wouldn’t have the courage to say whats really on my mind…I hope to find that courage one day. Blogging just has so much more substance to it than the likes of facebook…but for some reason I can’t bring myself to delete that account ha ha x
We’ve created a false need to share everything about ourselves and feel we need to be super happy to do so. We post too much, on impulse and lose the sense of what is important to us, and how we feel. I liked your list about what to consider prior to posting. Well done.
irunibreathe.wordpress.com
I am so glad I read this whole post. I had just stumbled upon your blog from the “Freshly Pressed” page and upon seeing your layout and photo and “About Me” section, was immediately struck with jealousy! As someone who just started a blog and is still very much figuring out its direction, I thought, now THIS is what a blog is supposed to look like; it is perfect in a way mine never will be…why am I even trying?!
Then I read your entry and realized how right you are about how misleading only parts of the ‘picture’ can be. That you have struggled with depression and are open about that reveals a humanity that I was both relieved and inspired by. Your writing is so impressive and this topic so relevant and important. Thank you! I cannot wait to read more.
Very interesting! I often have found myself thinking the same thing regarding status updates on facebook. There are those who only post their prettiest pictures or happiest moments, and you really get the impression that they want you to be green with envy. Then there are the ambiguous, emo statuses that seem to be an ego-boost or a “look at me” plea more than anything else. I’d be interested to hear what you think about my latest gossip post entitled “Is Your Confidence of No Consequence” as I think it touches on some of your interests as well, and you’re right, the whole point of social media is to engage others and have a conversation, not just vent until you’re blue in the face. :)
Ah! What an insighful and wonderful post. One of my post was limited Social Bragging (http://wp.me/p2feNk-tI). Stellar post!!! :)
Wow, what a thought provoking post. I often post things on my blog that different from the original content of the blog. Just small things that I want to share, to allow my readers into my life a little more. Although now, as I’ve read this post and some of the comments, it makes me think that I should be a little more thoughtful of what I write. Often, I whip off a blog post by adding some photos and writing as it pops into my head; my readers deserve more. A well written, thought provoking post is something I’m capable of. You’ve challenged me to prove it to myself and my readers. Thanks!
http://www.thetravellingsock.wordpress.com
Singularity 2033
Wow, this is such a great post! I’ve always put a lot of effort into each of my posts (research, development, etc.) but this makes me think of them on an entirely different level.
I really enjoyed reading this. My facebook is technically for my blog (radium rollercoaster) and I try not to be overly personal with it, because I like having my small group of friends and that’s it. I think that people shouldn’t have Facebook or Twitter, because it ruins the truth behind relationships, and it makes the big things in your life less big, because you waste time trying to tell the world about it, rather than enjoy the moment for yourself. People don’t understand how to be independent anymore.
I’ve always played guitar poorly, but after a couple of near life-ending strokes, decided that as I relearned how to play some of my favorite guitar licks/solos and songs, I would post videos and tablature I wrote for them in a blog, and not concern myself with anything more than they are fun for me, and useful to a few guitarists. That is easily one of my best run-on sentences in quite a while.
Perhaps I shouldn’t share every thought, everywhere I go…
Great post, and congrats on being freshly pressed.
Thank you for your thoughful post. I am one of those people who don’t like to be vulnerable but I wanted to share my struggles with people to maybe help them or let them know that they’re not alone with their struggles so that’s why I started my blog. I feel like I can be much more honest and open on my blog than I can on other social media sites and I am much more willing to do so.
Thank you for this post. I love the idea of “Things I’m afraid to tell you” and I will try it. It sort of reminds me of the Seinfeld episode when George told everyone the truth and had better results in life. “I’m George, I’m unemployed and I live with my parents…”
Yes, I just started my first ever blog about a week ago, and my first three posts do reflect some difficulties I was having, though I hope in a light-hearted manner. After reading your posts, however, I’m glad to say that I have started to get on to the real purpose of my website, which is discussing writing. True, it’s a little tentative just now, but I appreciate how you’ve set some limits so that I won’t be continually navel-gazing and being involved in intricate and involved introspection. Kudos to Truth and Cake, Rian.
Insightful and thoughtful post. I’m glad to know there are people out there who consider what they are thinking before putting it out into the world. Also, I do think there is something to be said about only posting happy stuff about their lives. Life isn’t always bubbly and happy. It’s just not possible. And people who are angry all of the time and spam FB with comments that are supposed to make you feel guilty just become noise. With my own blog, I’m hoping to to just be myself but put it into a general enough voice and perspective that I hope readers can relate to. But, by no means am I perfect. Of course not.
Recently, I wrote a post about my position on a certain issue that is of great debate in America. I worried about it at first, as I know people who would disagree with me. I thought long and hard about how I wanted to pose it so as to not appear that I’m standing on a soap box and pointing fingers. But I wanted it to be true to me. Even though it is a controversial issue, I did it because I felt it was a way to round out my online presence. Until that point, I wrote about photography, or things I thought were insightful or funny. But I confident enough about myself now in my life that sharing things that rock the boat, or things that come from the dimmer shadows of my mind, would be okay as long as I do it in a way that is accessible. If that makes sense.
Thank you for your thoughts. Congratulations on being freshly pressed!
Dear Fighting Reality, That’s the only bad thing I can see about such things as Twitter–(and I’m still debating about starting a Twitter account, though it’s enticing)–it focuses on sound bites much the way certain things in television news do. That is, it suggests that if you can’t say something short and sweet/sour don’t say anything. I wonder if it encourages us to think in depth about the things we read, such as the issue you say you worked so hard over presenting correctly. Probably you wanted people to think in detail about what your work implied, and sometimes a short newsblip remark may not cover it all.
Well-said! I do use my blog to share the harder stuff and I try to keep facebook light (although I keep it real, too). Sometimes it’s a difficult balance.
Congrats on being FP’ed!
Awesome post and so so true!
Reblogged this on funkdpunk.
could not say it better (:
Excellent post. Thoughtful and honest. Of course it is, Truth and cake – cake being the part thoughtful part. Assuming you don’t really want 5001 “takes” on social media, I invite you to check out my blog. It’s as honest as I can get without divulging unnecessary details about my life. Okay, not too many details. Maybe. : )
Reblogged this on Anti Eff Bee and commented:
I’m reblogging this because it’s really close to my own little Anti Eff Bee experiment, and I want to be able to find this again later.
I joined WordPress to start a blog about my life after I decided to metaphorically divorce myself from Facebook. Because it was literally ruining my life. How ironic that quitting FB brought me to WP, which in turn granted me this bit of unsolicited validation in my choice to reexamine my own motivations and actions as they pertain that site. It’s nice to know I’m not some maladjusted nutjob who can’t manage her social media, and that other people have noticed the things I’m seeing as well. And isn’t it nice when the Universe sees fit to give you a clearly marked “sign” that you’ve made a good decision in your life?
Thanks for being a Good Sign for me today. :)
Hey, I found this on freshly pressed and it made me think a lot about what I’ve been posting. This was a great post and I believe you accomplished what you were trying to tell others. Nice one.
Whew! I love this call to self-awareness and honesty in the social media morass, great stuff. I came late and reluctantly to Facebook (due to losing phone basically). I feel most of my “friends” (I tried to limit it at first to people whom I wholeheartedly could describe as such, but manners, and yes, perhaps a sneaky touch of nosiness/ comparison-drawing came into it and the numbers rose) use it in a similar way to me; we are all old enough to have forged our relationship with each other in the real, rather than virtual world and Social Media is just a secondary tool to stay connected. Even so, we are still knowingly or unknowingly self-editing, presenting one dimension (our ‘Face’) to the world. And mostly being careful with our privacy settings.
What concerns me is how this will all play out for those younger than us, whose friendships and relationships have been played out as much in the virtual as the real world from the outset; who will never have enjoyed a moment or experience for the “now” without already consigning it to a status update or Tweet before that experience is even over; who will never be able to pose carefree for a photo without the threat of an image of them looking gawky, ugly or drunk multiplying exponentially, spilling into the Newsfeeds of all their aquaintances and beyond, and existing for eternity in cyberspace.
I’m just glad I’m not young.
Hey! Love the topic, something I ponder all of the time (and occasionally write about). I think sometimes we forget that social is a form of communication. It is about interaction; and listening to others more than speaking yourself.
I think that when we aim to communicate with others, rather than ‘post’, the content we produce and display becomes more meaningful and connected. The amount you use social should be dictated by the amount you communicate with others.
We should all make an effort (myself included, it’s hard!) to use social for sparking or continuing conversation more often.
“The amount you use social should be dictated by the amount you communicate with others.” Great point. It is frustrating when someone puts a lot of “stuff” out there without engaging in any real way with others. I’m trying to omit pointless Facebook scrolling from my life. Why look at pictures if you’re not going to comment and connect in some way? I guess it’s a perspective shift–how and why do you use Social Media and is it healthy?
Great post. I agree, I can’t stand it when people throw up a post and just wait for their friends to reply with “hang in there hun” or “Whats wrong? Be brave” or whatever. Just people looking for attention to feel better about themselves.
Cheers!
Very thought provoking.Posting our weekly weight loss photos is very intimidating and embarrassing. Sometimes we wonder why we are doing it. But, I suppose we are mainly doing it for ourselves – it’s motivating to want to keep having better results each week. And, hopefully it will help anyone else wanting or trying to lose weight to feel motivated. I guess that’s our logic. But, it’s still a bit intimidating and embarrassing. Luckily (?) we don’t have much traffic on our blog so there’s always the comfort that no one is really looking anyway! :P
Congrats on being Fresh Pressed. We like your blog!
Maybe you’ll get more traffic now that you’ve commented on a ‘freshly pressed’ blog! Good luck!!
This blog post is great. I will admit to posting things that were motivated by sadness or revenge or other not so nice feelings. But I try hard to keep it real. You did a fabulous job with this!
This is possibly my favorite thing to talk about: social media and how it’s affecting society. I really appreciate how you encourage others to be open and just yourself; it seems like something nobody does anymore, although it makes sense why. I’ve watched my sister re-transform herself time and time again in order to give a different view of “who she is” to her Facebook friends.
As for me personally: this is really the only social media site I have. I deleted my personal facebook several months ago and only keep one around for my blog. I never bothered with Twitter. When I did have Facebook, I posted about usually positive things, I think — the exception being when I would go through my yearly depression. My blog is more just a collection of thoughts: day to day life, the good, the bad, and the really ugly.
Great post and so true. When I see some posts by friends that are very negative and depressing, it makes me uncomfortable. But, I think when people reach out with something that is honest, not negative, people will be more apt to respond and help. Really glad I stumbled across your blog!
wow, loved this entry. One of the reason why I actually deactivated my facebook was because of this issue. Even the “imperfect” things people say on facebook was intentionally written so that whatever they write, they would look good or get attention or what so ever. It’s hard to see who people truly are under that kind of context. Can’t really say that blogging escapes this completely, but there is still an element of truth that you can tell when you’re reading someone’s entry. You can tell whether it’s genuine or not.
You know, its very hard to disagree with what you say. I feel like our society today is so used to constant rewards, short-term satisfaction, everything instant, and striving for perfection that over time we have just been conditioned into self-centered human beings. We hunger for any possible means of gaining peoples’ attention because well, it’s what we’ve been taught as kids. I see children today being brought up to believe that they are god’s gift to the world, praised by their parents for every little thing that they do. Children are given awards in school for simply “trying”. For instance, in a Spelling Bee or Science Fair each child that does not win may be given a small award in order to protect them from the emotional blow of losing and to allow them to feel like they too are important rather than labeled a “Loser”. I’ve seen this done in so many schools today. I’m sorry, but what ever happened to just sucking. It’s okay to fail! It’s humbling! Well, at least to me. To me, failure puts you in your place and tells you hey, maybe you aren’t perfect. I feel like teaching our kids that they are always the “best” is just a means of perpetuating this society of self-centered, attention-seeking individuals who go on Facebook, posting just for the sake of gaining praise and not contributing much to the world.
Thanks for this … am all about honesty and find facebooking etc all a little fake NO ONE is atht perfect and I would rather meet up for a cup of coffee and a chat then fire off a twitter
Great post! I believe we connect with what we feel and when someone’s sharing their heart and soul…we feel it – it touches us and moves us.
When we dare to be ourselves and share that, it opens avenues for others to be OK with who they are and as I see it, that’s my mission as a blogger. :)
To get ones head around the concept of vulnerability being ‘a good thing’ takes a little time but undoubtedly it lets you connect better with others. Maybe it even makes one stronger in the process? The Facebook issue… I resisted Facebook for years, gave in and have found its use whilst travelling the world. Sure emails and phone calls are nicer but not always practical (short bursts spent in internet cafes or time differences and such like). And I like the fact that Facebook publishes links to my travel blog – it keeps a few of my buddies in the loop as to where I’m at. When I actually catch up in person again, whilst I catch up with what’s been going on back home, they want further details on my adventures (adventures that they already feel a bit conencted to). So I’ve found my peace with Facebook, in some respects.
I’m wondering, what will come along next?
Reblogged this on Bite Size Help and commented:
Nice observation of the carefully crafted image of ourselves online allows us to create…
Excellent Narration and you made me feel your words to be so very real.
Thanks for sharing. I am a new blogger who has a long way to go.
Last month I did away with Facebook. I debated on whether to join the blogging world after. I wanted to inspire and be inspired, yet I can be completely open while having some anonymity. How beautiful is that?
This is the first blog of yours I have read. Nice! Thank you.
i think this is great!
Great article!!!
I try to be honest and vulerable and to express myself as I feel.
However, I also refuse to engage in drama fights. Those drive me nuts and just feels like bad taste.
I like what you had to say here, and I completely agree with it all. This is definitely a very well thought out and intriguing article!
so true .. authenticity it goe’s a long way
We focus on the best version of the truth, editing out the bad parts and instagramming the rest until we look shiny and gleamy and well-adjusted.
- I guess that’s why they term it social networking. Don’t expect tons of followers/friends to socialize with you if you constantly portray a ‘Debbie Downer’. But you’re right, the thing is, we tend to sugarcoat ourselves & it’s scary because some ‘friendships/relationships’ right now are founded on mutual ‘likes’ & ‘following’.
Yes I do feel our method of communication is very disconnected, but I feel that there’s nothing we can really do about. People are getting attached to their most recently produced apple products and if you took it away it would be like taking away their most prized possesion. Its really sad, I feel so bad about that I’ve started composing letters to my friends instead of texting them. Also, I feel its necessary to use my letter writing skills because I learned about it in grade school for a reason!
Very interesting perspective. If a blogger sticks to a niche or target audience, then by definition the blogger is leaving things out that don’t fit in that niche. It happens. It’s nice when people choose to step outside boundaries from time to time, but I understand why we can’t always do that. If it’s authentic, then the fact that it is not all inclusive is okay with me. Great post.
I like what you had to say here, and I completely agree with it all. This is definitely a very well thought out and intriguing article!
Hi there! Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful post. It is very well written. And I completely agree with everything you said in this article.
Cheers,
Feliza
This is so interesting and helpful. I’m a new blogger, trying to walk the line between exposing my vulnerabilities in a constructive and hopefully entertaining way, while not revealing too much. This is a lot to think about!
Reblogged this on The Creative Mind of Chic.
I think I am pretty open when it comes to sharing. But in the spirit of this post I will be making my own post on things I am afraid to tell you.
Ill let you know how it goes
Reblogged this on Fashionmistgalore's Blog and commented:
Awesome*
Reblogged this on Fashionmistgalore's Blog and commented:
Awesome*
I loved your post as well! Thanks for writing such an insightful entry! I’m new to blogging, just a week into it and still getting my footing in the art of it. I’d like to be able to share my life and art through my blog, though there is a fine line between too much and not enough that I’m still discovering and your blog has brought to light the importance of finding that balance if you want to write something truly worth reading! So thank you!
Reblogged this on That Girl called Holly….
Need I use many sentences to say you’ve written on a good point very much nicely?
You raise some very interesting and valid points. However I slightly disagree with your statement that ‘revealing simply to unburden yourself is a bit selfish’. Sometimes you just need to get something out of your system (writing be a form of catharsis) without having to worry about whether it’s being written in the right context. Then again perhaps that is being selfish. But doing something just for yourself every now and again surely can’t be a bad thing :)
Very nice collection and I really enjoyed your blog.
Congratulations on being Freshly Pressed.Thought provoking stuff. I like the positive stuff. If I want to get depressed and fearful there is always CNN and Fox. We are all only one phone call away from crushing heartache but its no reason to sit in fear.(been there)However as a newbie blogger I do have to be conscious of motive. My purist motivation is that I want people(especially men) to experience the joy and sense of empowerment that comes with being handy.On the dark side I seek fame.
Keep up the good work
Back again on FP! Congrats. Not sure how my blog rates according to your protocols. Comment?
Wow, I just posted on my relationship with Facebook – how ridiculous is that statement alone? I was forced to confront the truth of my interactions with Facebook and they aren’t attractive or healthy and so this weekend I am ‘unfriending’ Facebook
loved the post! lovely photos to go along as well (:
wow this was wonderful. i have been ruminating over this a lot recently, to the point where i’ve considered taking myself off certain social media sites because i can’t stand the contrived nature of it all. but social media with mindfulness is a great idea and a movement i can definitely get behind!
I truly appreciated this post, and am thoughtfully examining myself and my recent blog posts, trying to assess the “real.” My goal has always been to just be me – triumphs and trials and all. Thanks for the inspiration to keep trying.
And congrats on being freshly pressed!
I feel like the context of the sharing matters a lot. I definitely think people share too much in some online contexts and (as you’ve said) give no context at all in other moments of sharing online (and therefore don’t really share enough). Venting is a good thing and one does wonder where the appropriate place to vent is… is it ever online? Should it just be with friends in person? Hmm… I don’t think I know the answers to my own questions.
Thanks for such a thoughtful post.
It’s probably a good idea a writer know herself and what is coming across on her page; it’s very nice if a reader senses this knowing. The sense that the writer has a handle on herself, particularly when sharing difficult material, takes the reader off the hook. Venting seems troublesome as it can lead readers to feel too responsible for you – it can also lead to voyeurism. I can only read such blogs for so long before I get bored – a classic signal indicating disengagement has occurred. Contrary to popular belief, I do not think venting in and of itself leads to greater self-awareness. My sense is it does the opposite – it winds up trapping the writer in the surface scum of her story. It’s even worse with blogging because the venting in and of itself is rewarded, as it becomes a magnet for others needing to keep similar stories alive in themselves, alive and undeveloped. Venting in and of itself keeps us from seeing all angles of our story, it keeps us from finding a way out. (now I’m venting about venting – ha ha ha).
I don’t want my readers to think simply because I’m sharing my vulnerability that they have to take care of me. But I do see this happening all over the blogosphere…people use blogs for therapy, which is fine, but to me this sort of writing should be better understood, the effects of it anyway. Sometimes it seems social media demands writers leave good writing (good thinking and feeling) at the door; the pace needed to gain connections/followers is such that without knowing it we begin to rely upon the exchange of cliched thought. We package our experience in buzz words and brands we know will attract followers. From what I’ve observed in my past 1.5 yrs of blogging, this is the norm. To buck this human trend, I’ve tried to concern myself a little less with gaining followers and a little more with writing something real. Some people are in a rush and prefer the convenience of a prepackaged meal…others, perhaps those with more time, prefer something homemade. I’m of the latter camp. So that’s the way I write. To me there’s nothing more rare and worthy of my time than authenticity.
Personally, I hide behind my blog. By being anonymous, it allows me to be completely open…completely free. Not having to worry about being judged is one of the most liberating things I could ever experience!!
-Savannah
xo
Extremely well put! I couldn’t agree more with everything you said, and it is scary how good friends almost hide behind facebook to make their lives appear so much more wonderful and less realistic than it truly is. We all know life is full of ups and downs and I value to people that are secure enough to embrace life in its fullness! I like you:)
Very nicely said. It’s so hard to share those things, especially on a blog – I find myself with one of those hyper-glossy “Disneyesque” blogs at the moment that oozes with adventure and happiness.This is not always the case in my life. It’s always a matter of what to share? How much to share? Who to share it with? Do we just go for it and hope people don’t think we’re shoving our private lives down their throats? Do we hope people will relate or approve? It’s always a tricky one – thank you for the well-thought out post!
I love this! First i would like to say that you are absolutely right. People tend to make their lives sound perfect or terrible,there is no in between. However,I feel that the “in between” is what makes us unique. I am an optimist so I try to see the better side of things. But i am human so being optimistic all the time is impossible. What i have learn during my short life is that it makes you feel better to be realistic and optimistic. Life isn’t perfect,nor will it ever be. But accepting what comes between the good and the bad makes either one easier to deal with. Though I know it’s easier said than done.
It’s definitely true and widely acknowledged that we select what we present to the web-world. It’s also obvious that we share way more than ever before… is it more substantial? Probably not. The questions you outlined might never be asked by those who post the most. I love how you presented a blogger as “a whole, imperfect human being”, but we also do select material, context, facts that we present… it’s good to think about our motivations though. Great post, so much food for thought!
well written!
Yes yes yes to all of what you wrote! I stated the other day on FB after scrolling through what must have bbeen30 or more posts in a row of those cutesy motivational pictures, that my FB was looking like the billboards on an interstate. I believe there is a time and place to discuss and divulge the pain a person needs to share, but there also has to be more transparency in all this social media we seem to connect with these days.
I’m very happy to read your frank truth; it was very refreshing.
How I loved the simplicity of your expression in a very common but complicated issue of our dailiy sharing… Do you mind if I translate it to Turkish (my native language) and press it? Of course without any alterations…
Thanks for this great post. I’ve been following your blog for a few months now and everything you write is very meaningful and amusing. What you said about motivations is very true – I started blogging almost a year ago because I needed to practice writing (I’m from Brazil, so English is not my native language) and I needed a personal project to invest some time on. It’s been great exercise so far but mostly a narcisistic and cryptic one, since I’m still finding the balance for sharing enough without feeling too vulnerable. It’s a learning process! But I trust that I’ll get there eventually. Thanks for the insights.
Thanks for following–I really appreciate it! Blogging is an exercise in constant change and adaptation–I’m sure you’ll figure out what feels right for you. Kudos to you for blogging in your second language! Take care.
I feel like ALL I see online is mindless complaints. Perhaps it is because I am such an optimist that I LIKE to see all the happy postings.
Hi Rian! Great job! You r blog is so refreshing and while going through your other posts , I saw your offer to FP ourselves
.thanks for the opportunity, http://modupeore.wordpress.com/2011/10/18/as-i-sat-there/
Okay, so I still have a lot to learn about blogging and sharing links but at least, am putting myself out there. :-))
BTW, the link resonates with your post about waking up….and I totally accept the terms of this agreement. Read at least 3 posts of others’ & leave comments, not a problem cos the only rival to writing in my life, is reading.
Hi Lily, would you mind copying and pasting this comment onto the original Freshly Press Yourself post so that others can see it? Thanks!
I love this post. Could completely relate to it. I have been through depression as a teenager as well and now at 20,i am learning to cope with it. Taken up a challenging job as a reporter and determined to make it in this field! Have no qualms whatsoever in displaying the not so awesome part of my life on facebook or wordpress.
Reblogged this on My 2 cents and commented:
I’ve wanted to write on this subject myself and perhaps I will one day. But for now read someone who already said it very very well.
Yes, it seems to be true that we do pick and choose how to communicate to protect our vulnerability. Nonetheless, there seems to be an emerging thread of character over time in multiple posts. I am contempting how we (and I) post visual media and thereby avoid in-depth discussion. Your post is good example of a mixed-media communicating a textual point. Your thought?
Love the Picture for the blog!
Well said!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you!
Very interesting. I’ve noticed that social media often doesn’t bring people happiness–very often it’s the opposite. I work in social media right now, but I don’t use it for personal matters. It makes me feel detached from the real world. Looking forward to the next post!
New reader here. This is very thoughtful and insightful. I often wonder if I read something and immediately think it’s contrived…then perhaps it is.
Actually, i have just started a blog a few months back, and am refusing to publicize it on FB and Twitter, and get it linked back to me. With FB and its excessive flow of information, people in general are no longer patient enough to understand, to find out the real situation, to think deeply. I find that a kind of regression for us as human beings. With our level of education and quality of life, we should be finding more time and making more effort to think deeply and synthesize solutions.
As much as i like the “like” button (and how i wish there is one on every comment!), i still think that it is a lazy way to make connections and to give approval to our friends when they say something brilliant. By starting a blog (and not for the purpose of increasing readership to boost my ego :)), I want to go back to browsing, and reading things taht interests me, or stumble upon something that might surprise me, and to share my thoughts with like-minded people.
Reblogged this on Manila Pop!.
I agree totally with this. Especially the paragraph on context. I wish I could do it though. I always feel the need to hold back something. And I know it shows through. Part of the reason I started blogging was to help solve this problem. It just highlights how much I still have to grow. If I may quote the late great Bon Scott from AC-DC, “It’s a long way to the top…”
I have to say that I agree with you,check out my post Reality!
For the most part I agree, but I believe that to claim “Revealing simply to unburden yourself is a bit selfish. Don’t just vent.” is harsh, if not incorrect – people have different reasons to start a blog, be it boredom, a wish to share life lessons or simply the need to vent. If you don’t want to read something because you believe it’s irrelevant, just don’t. ;)
Reblogged this on This beautiful life.
In the past hour i have been a bit bummed. i deactivated my facebook aswell. Why? because I don’t like how some people can sit there and say grammar and spelling can tell you if someone is worth your time. Yes there are mixed opinions on this. But my opinion still stands and that someone is not defined by their spelling or grammar and everyone is worth someones time (dont judge someone until you have walked in their shoes.)
I am glad i stumbled across this just now, because i also have a post on my blog about social media such as facebook.
Personally i think people are just so negative towards each other on facebook, so many people are out to prove people wrong and so quick to point out their flaws. People are affraid of posting what their life if currently really like, because they are affraid of being attacked about their flaws.
For some reason people on facebook are on the edge of their seat all the time, just waiting to pounce on someone – Grammar and spelling being most common.
(people dont consider things like learning disabilitys, life story and maybe not being able to go to school)
Thankyou. This post made me happy :)
I totally get you. FB is another place where we can’t be caught off guard, and “have to” be cool. We already have to be all perfect in the workplace, social meet ups, in front of our extended families. We have to be so online too, lest we will be judged and attacked! That’s tiring.. What happened to just living life? I think with all these unnecessary pressure, our youth won’t grow up feeling confident. For every FB post, we would have to hire an editor and PR manager ;)
I delete stupid people who think their smarter than me, or plain negative. When they are thrown away, THEY in turn will be worried. Ego boost outlet….. kapooof!
you are right, sadly though the people who keeps doing this is are ex-tended family members of my fiance. so even though i dont have most on facebook, i still cop the crap. its as if they are trying to tell me something lol. i do understand they dont like me and think im stupid, because unlike them i am not studing writing at uni, or i dont watch movies all the time and talk about high tea’s and the joys of reading books that dont help me at all.
i read self-help books to review them on my blog and on facebook, i am studing business, dont have much time to watch movies or talk about tea partys i never have.
I am not sure if they want me to be more like them. I dont want to be like them. I dont want to sit at home dreaming and not doing. I want to do the things i want without having them call me stupid, i want to write a post on facebook and not have someone say my grammar sucks.
-_- it must be too much to hope for.
I feel this break from facebook with help clear my head from the negative, but i fear my return will just bring it all back. or maybe it will have inproved. i know i would have. :)
thankyou for your comment replying to mine. i am so glad i am not the only one out there who feels this way.
Hmmm, that is unfortunate, i am so sorry to hear that… I guess people are just not opened minded. I always reason that there are already more than 6 billion people on earth, and if the earth consist of only one type of people, it would have been a boring and drab place.
Next time, do write reviews about business related books… and see the negativity disappear! They have just lost control of their comfort zone hahaha!
Good luck, and thanks for liking my blog :)
I do not want to publicize my blog on my own FB page, cuz then, i would be pressured to write to please them, because i will know my audiences. Not fun, better to fly solo!
Thanks so much for this post Rian. I am very new to the world of blogging and you have made me think very carefully about the direction I want to take my blog. I think, like most areas of the world, balance is the key to meaningful and healthy social media use. It seems to be about figuring out where that line between public and private falls for each person in each situation – in other words, when to status update and when to just call your best friend for advice.
Nice post.
People are affraid of posting what their life if currently really like, because they are affraid of being attacked about their flaws.
In Facebook, you post mainly to your friends. In stead of “like”, my favorite button in Facebook is the one where you can hide others’ updates. Sometimes you just don’t want to see the stuff others have to say.
I prefer more personal messages than Facebook. http://www.keeptree.com is a good way of keeping in touch with friends and family, sending them greetings, jokes – whatever. I have also kept private video diary for myself, and sent videos to be delivered in the future. Keep Tree is like if Skype and YouTube had a baby – more personal than Youtube, and way easier to use than Skype, since you don’t need simultaneous internet connection with the person you’re sending videos to. Are you already using Keep Tree? There is nothing better than receiving a surprise message from someone you (didn’t even realize you) missed.
Interesting post, I’ve been following the social media animal closely & have written something just today :-)
Firstly, I love your blog!! I want to print this out and show everyone of my friends. Your blog is beautifully presented and I see the connection you said a blogger must make. Thank you for inspiring me to start my own blog. I’ve always felt so timid about my inner feelings. I think blogging will loosen me up. Thanks again! love,xoxo
Keep Tree is like if Skype and YouTube had a baby – more personal than Youtube, and way easier to use than Skype, since you don’t need simultaneous internet connection with the person you’re sending videos to.