Pictures or It Didn’t Happen: Thoughts From a Compulsive Photographer
Truth and Cake
Posted on August 30, 2012

A photo of me taking a photo in Tofino. Image by David Narvas.
It’s hard to remember a time before I took photographs. My first camera, a hot pink rectangle that ran on 110 film, was amongst my favorite possessions as a child. I’d loop the thin white rope around my neck and snap away at anything deemed worthy of immortalization: my dolls, the backyard, the stilted man at Pier 39. Most of these shots were fuzzy and boring—often too close or crooked, many featuring my own gap-toothed smile. I don’t remember cataloguing and sorting my photos with any sort of voracity. Mostly, it was about pushing the button, hearing the click, relishing the notion that the image had been captured.
My urge to record moments only increased as I grew older. I have boxes of significant as well as un-noteworthy photos and their accompanying negatives: the awkward adolescent years, the happy faces of my high school friends squished into a tiny frame, prom dresses, university parties, posing backstage before a show. And, as my mom always likes to point out, pictures of my feet—red shoes standing in piles of bright red leaves or yellow rain boots next to a clump of soggy seaweed. Perhaps it is my way of saying, “Here I am,” or, more accurately, “Here I was.”
I can’t begin to guess at a single all-encompassing reason why I and so many others feel this compulsion to document the mundane aspects of our lives. If I speak for only myself, I could say I take pictures because the only constant in my early life was change. I moved almost every year, attending a different elementary school annually, swapping out friends like some people swap clothing trends. This made me adaptable, but also clingy—I wanted to capture time and take it along with me. So I filled journal after journal with words and, upon receiving that handy pink box, took endless photographs. Here was a way to prove to myself that I had, in fact, lived in that place and known those people—people I would never see again, places I have yet to revisit.

Me with my trusty (and very pink) camera.
But that doesn’t account for the scores of other compulsive picture takers out there. Some people who begin taking photographs at an early age become professional photographers; the rest of us are merely image hoarders, amateurs, hobbyists.
Susan Sontag’s brilliant collection of essays, On Photography examines the many reasons we take photos: to remember, to assuage anxiety, to attain a sense of power, “to appropriate the thing photographed.” She notes that “people robbed of their past seem to make the most fervent picture takers.”
Today, I rarely leave the house without a camera. Before iPhones, that meant toting along my point-and-shoot Canon or my clunky Nikon. I’ve often been the girl at a party aiming a huge black DSLR at my friends, capturing a candid moment or a smiley couple shot. Now I, and so many others, can hide behind the fact that it’s only a phone, a device we have to carry anyway. And why not take a quick shot of that sunset or beautiful meal? It’s only a harmless finger swipe on a screen. So simple.

But it’s not. My hard drive is completely full of photographs, my Facebook page overflows with albums. Despite spending thousands of dollars on professional photos, I took pictures at my own wedding. My friends rely on me to document parties and outings, to proffer Facebook profile pictures: I, in turn, rely on that definition of myself as a provider of memories. But where is the line? No longer reined in by the 24 shots on a roll of film, everything has become a moment worth capturing. Parents of small children can find this especially challenging. What smile, step or new achievement isn’t photo-worthy?
But are we creating memories before we even experience them? Sontag believes the photograph may be replacing the memory entirely:
Ultimately, having an experience becomes identical with taking a photograph of it, and participating in a public event comes more and more to be equivalent to looking at it in photographed form. That most logical of aesthetes, Mallarmé said that everything in the world exists in order to end in a book. Today everything exists to end in a photograph.
Not only are we drowning in jpeg files, we’re quite possibly allowing those images to replace our experiences.
But how do we stop?
Maybe, now and then, by just…stopping. By stepping back and looking longer and harder at the people and places around us, seeing them for what they are instead of analyzing them for photo ops.
I’m getting ready to take off for my annual Labor Day trip to the Okanagan. Usually, surrounded by so many friends and beautiful sights, I would spend a significant amount of time peering through a viewfinder. Not this time. For the next four days, I’m not going to take a single photograph. It’s something I’ve never done before. And already, it feels like a phantom chapter: will I remember the fun I had if there are no pictures? The answer, of course, is yes, as much as we can remember anything past that single frozen moment.
I’m looking forward to a break from the constant horizon-scan. Maybe someone else will take photos. Maybe not. For once, capturing the moment won’t be reliant on that old familiar click.
What about you? Do you take a lot of pictures? Rely on others to document important moments? Have you ever gone on a trip and refrained from snapping a single photo?


This becomes more and more relevant! I attempted a similar task regarding picture taking when I went on vacation this year as well. I attempted to take it back a notch by using a disposable camera instead of my phone in order to capture the moment but avoid the temptations of social media.
A disposable camera–that’s a cool idea, Becca. I haven’t used one of those in years :) How did it work out for you? Would you do it again?
I would absolutely do it again. It was not only nostalgic but helped me stay focused on the actual moment while still capturing it for later. One slight problem: the button got stuck half way through the trip, so I only ended up with 15 photos unfortunately. At least I know to be more careful next time.
Oh I so agree! Recently we started out on a trip and an hour away from hom, we discovered he camera was left at home. Didn’t deter us from having a great time. Many times my husband has missed seeing a totally great vista because he is trying to adjust settings on his camera. He misses the shot as well. So going sans camera might be a good idea.
Missing the moment and the shot–definitely a sign to be in the moment! I’ll keep that in mind :)
I take lots of photos but then I cull them ruthlessly and only keep the best – not necessarily the best shot, but the one that is most evocative of the moment. As a teenager, I had a camera and was only limited by the processing costs of film. Now that we have digital cameras, there is no such limit. Our children have a camera – a $200 point and push – and all of them at various times have used it to photograph the television, their toys and pets and in one random case, another photo! We (the grown ups) have a nice Canon which lets us play more. Interestingly, two of our older children LOVE to use the big camera and the others are completely uninterested!
I’m having the debate as to whether to take the big camera with me on my overseas trip next week. I have 3 days in the Napa Valley with one of my best friends in the world, and the thought of her, and the light is totally tempting. Then I have a week in Dublin working, but no doubt I will be released from time to time, and there are all those beautiful buildings and people. Then I’m in Sydney for work for another week and the possibility of people photos there at our work events is endlessly appealing. I have to offset against that carrying the camera bag on all those planes and through all those airports…
It sounds like you’re finding the balance between being in the moment and recording the moment. Lovely post as always!
Hi Lisa–Man, I wish I had your patience/ability to edit and delete photos. I struggle to edit them down, wondering if what I deem important now will change later. Your trip sounds amazing–Napa, Dublin and Sydney. Those are definitely photo worthy spots. If it were me, I would definitely be lugging the camera bag ;) I hope you have a fantastic time!
I should say that I think my husband may have kept every digital photo we’ve ever taken stored away on a disk somewhere…I am compromising on the camera for the trip! I am taking the camera, but not the big lens. That way I can fit the camera bag into my laptop bag (has to go for the work part of the trip). I can always borrow my friend’s big snout in Napa if I need to. I can’t possibly do an overseas trip without a camera and the one on my Blackberry just isn’t good enough!
I’m the worst. I have to capture everything until everybody gets really annoyed. But I keep thinking I’m HELPING. I’m helping. Right? I don’t understand why people keep saying, “oh why did you post THIS photo or THAT photo – I look terrible!” or similar. I have a friend who is an aggressive deleter of photos of her that were not perfect to the point that she was sneakily or violently steal my camera to cut off the never ending shame it might cause her. I think we’re a good match… Maybe.
Your comment made me laugh out loud. “An agressive deleter of photos”-ha! Sounds like your friend needs you around in order to keep her self image in check ;) A good match, indeed.
My family wasn’t big picture takers when I was a kid, but especially when we were all grown up. Groaning when my grandmother insisted on taking pictures. But I tell you, I wish it had been different. My mom died 5 years ago and she was my very best friend and I can’t find one photo of us together. Ridiculous. My husband is making sure my daughter has plenty of pictures of us together, and he could skip a few in my opinion. I think we all just need to find balance.
I’m so sorry to hear of your loss. I hope one day, you stumble across a long lost photo of the two of you. How wonderful that your husband is dutifully documenting your relationship with your daughter–I’m sure she will cherish those photos one day. Take care.
I am a mad collector of photos too. I have always had a camera and am the one on the back side. In fact I am so obsessed the Fashion Mister and I travel with two cameras…not counting our phones. In part because I am a control freak and like to do pictures my way. :)
However, I set aside times when the camera stays put because sometimes I just want to live in the moment and enjoy the experience.
I’m sure someday I will be the little old lady in the nursing home, surrounded by photo albums (or some future equivalent), running my memories of the past over and over on an endless loop.
Cheers,
Laura
I think that’s where the balance lies: allowing your photographer brain to rest sometimes and giving yourself full permission to snap away at others. Don’t worry, I’m sure I’ll be right beside you with my multi-volume albums. We can swap photos!
And stories!
:D
I totally relate to this post. If I see a sunset or a sunrise I MUST have a photo of it. How many sunset photos can you have I ask?
That’s the million dollar question, isn’t it? ;)
This is something I too struggle with, reminding myself from time to time just to put the camera away and experience the moment. And yet, I am such a visual person that memory remains vivid when I record the image and can return to it. The desktop image I have at the moment is a photograph from my recent trip in the Broken Islands, and when I look at it, I am immediately calmed.
Have fun in the Okanagan! Have you ever visited my favourite little winery up there called Wild Goose?
I haven’t! I see that it’s near Okanagan Falls. I’ll suggest it to the group if we head that way. Thanks for the tip!
This was such an interesting post. I am not a photographer, and have no interest in taking photos – they stop me from enjoying the event. I only take photos as a way to record an event. But I do have a friend that we all rely on to take photos as she is so good at it. I sometimes wonder if it is a burden on her.
I imagine your friend just enjoys taking photos– if she’s anything like me, it’s her natural inclination and not a burden. It’s been interesting swapping roles these last two days–people aren’t used to seeing me without a camera and they have to take more of their own shots. It can be good to change the dynamic now and then, that’s for sure.
yes, of course she does, or I imagine she wouldn’t do it:) I would be surprised to see her anywhere without her camera…
Yes, I guess compulsive would be the word. Much like any addict looking forward to the next fix, I find myself anticipating the time I can spend taking, editing and sharing photos. I’m reluctant to investigate the reasons, and instead am just following what feels like a drive to create art.
I haven’t found this interferes much, since I don’t take many photos when I want to be really present for an event or gathering.
Thanks for the thought-provoking post. I will probably pick up that Sontag book.
I’m on vacation right now and have taken numerous photos already, this is so timely as while my daughter, Marlie, was riding the carousel or eating the huckleberry ice cream dipped in chocolate today, I was asking her to stop, smile, look at me… then I thought, “Why do I interrupt her joy for a photo op?” It’s ice cream or riding a wooden horse, it’ll happen many times after this moment and has happened many times before. I think it’s the memory bit, keeping memories tangibly rather than within oneself as well a sharing the moment with others; be it texting, email, online albums etc.What a great goal for you, no photo snapping. You’ll have to let us all know how it goes, Rian. Hope you have a wonderful trip!
Hi Kristy, huckleberry icecream and carousels, sounds like so much fun. I think you’re right–we experience something beautiful or wonderful and we have this huge impulse to keep (and share) it with others. And those are positive motivations. It’s when we just snap and snap and snap that it starts to interfere with (and actually become) the experience. Even though carousels and icecream will happen again, I’m sure you’ll be glad for that memory one day. Enjoy your vacation! xx
Good blog! I don’t take many pictures precisely for the reason you give: I want to savor the moment and taking a picture tends to dismiss the moment. Unfortunately, my memory isn’t as good as it used to be and I wish I had some photos of places I visited in England (for example) that are now just a fuzzy memory. But I think your plan to leave the camera behind is a good one: I do believe we take in more of what is going on around us with us when we just look, listen….and smell.
Wow, I wish I was able to be as in the moment as you are. I suppose the key is finding a middle ground: taking enough photos to remind you of the good times but not so many that the act of photographing interferes with your good times.
Dear Rian,
I am so sorry to ask the question: I followed ALL your blogs, but did not quite understand it: in one blog you shared PROFESSIONAL photos of your wadding noting it was worth the money invested and in this blog, you are writing (God, I could not believe my eyes, – so naive I am) that “Despite spending thousands of dollars on professional photos, I took pictures at my own wedding” – which content should I rely on since now on?! Your better be consistent. Because we BELIEVE your content and what you are writing!!!
Best,
Svetlana Bekhtereva, your admirer (Moscow, Russian Federation)
Hi Svetlana–I apologize if I was unclear. I was simply saying that in addition to the professional photos, I also took some of my own. My Maid of Honor kept my camera for me, knowing that I probably wouldn’t be able to resist the urge to take some of my own photos. Even though the day was thoroughly documented (by both professionals and friends) I still felt compelled to take pictures. The photos featured in the wedding post were taken by our wonderful professional photographers, Bebb Studios. Hopefully that clears things up for you.
Take care,
Rian
Yes, Rian, I took a month trip to South-East Asia (Laos, Cambodia, Vietnam, China, Hong-Kong, Bangkok) – and did not make any photo! Why should I?! Everything is already snapped by Susan Zontag and in photo albums, all my mimories are at my momory/brain and I do not have to shout the World, – look, I was here!..Envy me!.. My self-esteem is steady…
First, the idea of taking pictures of your feet is fantastic and under appreciated. I took a group of college students to Italy a fews ago and one assignment was to take a picture of their feet in their favorite spot. At first, they thought I was nuts (not the first time I’m sure). However, back home months later they cherished their photos. It brought on the “wow, I was really there” moment that opened the floodgates of fantastic memories of such an amazing place. Second, my grandmother just passed away and going hough the years of photos from many family and friends helped more than I anticipated in remembering the fun we had and the milestones in our own lives as well as hers. As our own memories begin to lag, photos can fill in the gaps. Now that “digital film free” shoot away!!!
What a cool assignment–glad to hear I’m not the only one who enjoys a good feet shot ;) I’m sorry to hear about your grandmother’s passing but happy that you have a plethora of photographic documentation of your time together. I love looking through old photos–so many stories and memories!
I do take a lot of pictures, not so many since the stroke; Reason? I simply forget to bring the camera. However, when I bought my own personal digital camera, I made certain it would handle any emergency. It runs on AA batteries and with the chip installed will take 4,000 pictures before they have to be erased or downloaded (which is a breeze).
So, with digital, I don’t worry about a bad picture; I just take another.
Scott
I do take a lot of pictures when I travel, but I have gone a long time without taking any pictures too. I have to be in the mood & sometimes I have no desire, so i don’t
Hi Dan-nice to hear from you! You’ve taken some amazing and important photos. Some things are really worth documenting, so thanks for sharing your experiences overseas with the rest of us. I appreciate it!
thank you for the kind words.
I’m definitely a photo junkie as well. My shot of choice, though, is a candid. I absolutely love when an unexpected moment captured on camera seems to embody the truth so well! While I do agree that photos might be replacing memories, I also know that for me, taking pictures is just a medium through which I experience my surroundings and my world. I think there is a way to find a happy medium between this experience and the human connection that it sometimes trades off with.
I came to some of these same realizations this year. I realized I was spending more of my time taking photos than actually enjoying my vacation for what it was and made a conscious effort to put the camera away….but then later I regretted not having the pictures, so I just don’t know. There’s got to be a middle ground but I don’t know what it is.
You’re right, and I think there is a middle ground. If we’re super stressed about enjoying and remembering every moment in lieu of photos, that may not work. But do we have to take photos of everything, or even take them every day of a trip? That’s what I’m starting to think about. Sometimes I’m feeling artistic and I want to try out different angles and snap away. But if I’m hanging out with my husband, having a great time, do I really need five shots of the same building? That’s where I’m trying to find the middle ground. Who I’m with, what I’m doing, that sort of thing. I hope you find your middle ground too. Good luck!
Ooo, good post. I know that my compulsive photo taking, especially on my iphone, are really a conversation to myself. Things I would share with people, if people were around. And I do share when friends and family sometimes but many of my photos are only for myself. My memories to document that I did exist in that place at that time, although the time becomes indistinct eventually.
I’ve found that occasionally I like to just leave all my devices at home. Phone included. No temptation to view the world through technology and to just experience the moment as I’m in it. These times feel great! …. but I don’t remember them after awhile.
Perhaps just take one group shot of your family/friends at the end of your time together, to remember the rest of the experience by? Or hold out like you would with film, for that one super brilliant shot to showcase your environment. Or no shots at all.
My brother-in-law told me about a man that went on a world-traveling adventure and never took a single picture! I couldn’t believe it! The more I thought about it though, I could see his point. He wanted to remember (like in his brain!) all of the places, the smells, tastes, emotions, and vistas. What a novel idea. I haven’t tried this, usually because I am so anxious to share my travels and adventures with family and friends (and now on my blog). I have always been the camera-toting kind, and now it has just become my role. I’m not sure I’m ready to stray from that, but you made me think about it! I’m proud of you for leaving the camera at home :) Happy Labor Day!
Hi Tobi–I have to say, it was sort of liberating. I was able to leave my role as “memory keeper” behind and just hang out. I actually enjoyed it (though I still felt a few twinges when there was gorgeous light). I don’t think I could do it all of the time, but I do think I’ll try it again. And, more importantly, I’m going to try and hold onto that feeling of being more in the moment when I’m hanging out with friends and family. When I decided to go photo-free for the trip, a friend sent me a Ted Talk about a guy who hitchikes everywhere. In it, he said, “I don’t take pictures. I like to be part of the bigger picture.” I like that idea :) I hope you had a wonderful Labor Day weekend!
I’m glad I’m not the only one who obsessively snaps away at every opportunity. I think I can be really annoying about this. I went to London this summer, and although I have a great visual documentation of the trip, I kept thinking of every moment in terms of, ‘I HAVE to take a picture of this!” This caused a lot of neck strain. I think I may need to tone it down, but I really can’t. haha!
I have to admit, I have always loved taking photos, but lack of a good camera in my later years of life (In high school, I had my grandma’s Cannon AE-1 35mm until the shutter mechanism stopped working) dissuaded me from taking massive quantities of snapshots. …But now that I have an iPhone, and discovered Instagram, I take ten pictures to get one good shot, I don’t want to take the time to “aggressively” delete the bad ones, and end up with TONS on file on my computer. Now that I have established my blog I take even more photos. Today was the first time I went out for a run and consciously chose not to take my phone – not recording any images or my mileage on Nike+. Incidentally, I may need to make this a habit; leave the iPhone at home at least once a week because being camera-less was rather liberating!
Ha, I can really relate, Alaina! I love to take photos when I run on the seawall in the evenings, it’s so pretty. But I’m scaling back a bit. Because I can’t post every single photo I take and the truth is, there’s probably going to be another gorgeous sunset tomorrow! Good luck, I hope you can fit a bit more camera free time into your life. I also find it liberating!
I can´t imagine going on a break and not taking my camera. I do try to find a balance between recording the event (so I can look back and be reminded of things I might have otherwise have forgotten) and enjoying the moment.
I agree with some others though, I really must delete unwanted images more ruthlessly!
Hi Marianne, I can definitely relate to your sentiment. I thought it was going to be an impossible task, but it was actually pretty easy. I’d recommend giving it a go sometime just to see how it feels. If you do, let me know how it goes!
Pictures on .jpeg files are far more durable than memories. Memories blur, fuse with other non-connected memories or get in the wrong order. A camera I guess is more reliable.
It’s the same with me and my diary – I write up events but I remember the words I wrote down, not the events themselves. I don’t think taking a lot of pictures are bad per se, I think it’s a human desire to record the world around us.
The problem is when we take pictures without pausing to savour or truly appreciate the beauty taking place in front of us: we point & shoot without really looking, and then The Moment (that particular sunset, the look on a face) passes us by and we can’t experience it again. The resulting photograph does not equal that Moment…
I can definitely relate to this. I resisted digital cameras way longer than everyone I know, because I do love film, but when I switched I was delighted by how much money I saved and how many more pictures I could take. It’s a little out of hand, but I make up for it by deleting agressively. I love my photos though. I love looking at them and I still love printing the best ones and putting them in bookes.
Ah–the photograph! I find it interesting that you brought up what Sontang said regarding the photograph almost replacing the memory. I know for myself, I sometimes let the idea of capturing the “perfect moment” override the enjoyment I actually feel in that moment. Especially with things like social media where we put our lives on display for everyone and anyone to see. Photographs almost become like little “proofs” that we have done something or that we are actually making memories, when quite often, we aren’t really even appreciating them for what they are when they’re happening. That being said, I am way too addicted to things like Instagram where I do have the convenience to so easily snap a photograph and store it away in the files. Maybe you have already read it, but if you have a chance to get your hands on an article titled “The Work of Art in the Age of Its Technological Reproducibility” by Walter Benjamin, I strongly suggest that you read it! It’s really fascinating and discusses how the technological developments of the camera and of film has affect the idea of the “image” and photographs in general. It is quite interesting. I hope you enjoyed your labour day weekend trip! Happy September, Rian :)
Thanks for the article suggestion, Amber! I will definitely check it out. You’re so right that the line between photographing for photography’s sake and photographing as a form of “proof” is becoming seriously blurred. I found my photo-free weekend to be incredibly relaxing. It was like flipping a switch. I didn’t constantly search for photo opportunities. I just let it all go. I definitely won’t be making that break permanent. But I think I will do it now and again. I hope you also had a wonderful Labor Day weekend. Happy September to you–good luck with your classes :)
Wow, so how was it not taking any pictures?! This is another fabulously written post, and something I think about a lot, because my mom is an avid (though amateur) photographer, and I hardly EVER take pictures because I can rely on her.
I’ve been taking more pictures lately for zee ol’ blog (a big reason why I got the iPhone), but I do still have that feeling that it takes me out of the moment and looking for photo ops instead of seeing the moment as it is. But I’m eternally grateful to the photographers in my midst because I LOVE having the pictures to look back on. (My ‘inheritance’ is my mom’s beautiful albums; I’m obsessed with them.)
Is there anything your mom can’t do? Fold fitted sheets, make beautiful photo albums, produce talented children… Does she hire herself out cause I think I could use a week or two with Babs around.
It actually went really well, which surprised me! I thought I was going to be itching to snap just one shot. But I realized that it’s this whole other part of your brain, a part that definitely needs a rest now and then. After the first day, I stopped looking at my surroundings as photo opportunities. I actually felt like I looked at the scenery less and at my friends more, which is a good thing.
I love taking photos, looking for good light and great compositions, and that won’t change. But I need to be in the moment a bit more sometimes and not so obesessed with missing a great shot. Grant even took one photo, which he hasn’t done in ages! Usually he’s rolling his eyes at me. So, hopefully this brings back a bit of balance. Lucky you to have someone to document it all for you! But be careful, Instagram sure is addictive ;)
So glad I discovered your blog, and look forward to following future posts. My name is travelgardeneat and I am a compulsive photographer. As time has gone on, I do think I have become better about reminding myself to step back and enjoy the moment, live in the moment — not just record the moment. I think the desire to take those photos is a desire to preserve those memories, and it is wonderful to have those zillions of digital shots to peuse, and relive the moments more vividly than the mind alone might be able to do. I have a simple Canon PowerShot, but find that even if it is not the most technically stunning photo, it often perfectly preserved a memory worth keeping or sharing. Since, ultimately, life is all about those memory moments, can that be such a bad thing?